Educational Research Analysts
  May 2007 Newsletter 
page
 3
2006 6th grade Math textbook ratings

Texas approved these 6th grade Math programs for 2007 local adoption.

BEST Saxon Math – Course 1  ( Harcourt Achieve, 2007 )
GOOD Math – Course 1  ( McDougal, 2007 )
FAIR Holt Math – Course 1  ( Holt, 2007 )
FAIR Texas Math – Course 1  ( Prentice, 2008 )
POOR Texas Math – Course 1  ( Glencoe, 2007 )
VERY POOR Everyday Math  ( McGraw, 2004 )     NONCONFORMING*
WORST Connected Math 2  ( Prentice, 2008 )

This ranking shows how much practice those programs provide in adding, subtracting, multi­plying, and dividing fractions and decimals; how quickly they teach problem-solving meth­ods; and how well they build personal math skills. It applies to grades 7-8 too, since each respective program will repeat there the pedagogies identified in grade 6. Along with our sum­mary comparison chart on those, we can furnish you with 11 more pages of detailed docu­men­tation.

Publishers tout teaching aides. We stress subject matter content. Publishers tell you their strengths. We include their weaknesses. No textbook pub­lisher funds us in any way. We have no financial stake in the textbook industry. Unlike publisher sales reps, we have no monetary interest in any adoption outcome. Our support comes from individuals and a few small foun­dations, which to our knowledge have no ties to any textbook company.

* The Texas textbook review panel found that Everyday Math was "nonconforming"
because it meets only 64.10% of Texas 6th grade Math TEKS (Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills) course standards.
See pp. 1-3 of the panel's findings.


For full, fast, FREE documentation, use our request form OR send us an email !